Hippo Staff Writer · Published 9 July 2024 · Updated 4 July 2026 · 3 min read

5 reasons why cancelling your Car Insurance is a bad idea

Woman facing crossroads, thinking about cancelling her car insurance

It’s tough out here. Petrol prices, interest rates and food price hikes have put us all in the grips of a cost-of-living crisis. Everyone is looking at ways to reign in the budget and cancelling their car insurance is one of those ways.

 

We get it – paying car insurance can feel like a grudge purchase, especially if you’ve never needed to claim for anything.

 

But hold on before you make a hasty decision you might regret. Canceling your car insurance is a risky move that could end up making your financial situation much worse. Here’s why cancelling your car insurance is a bad idea:

 

#5 Your bank won’t allow it

One big reason not to cancel your car insurance is that you might not be allowed to.

 

If your car is financed by a bank or lender, your contract may require that you have it comprehensively insured throughout your loan term. Cancelling your insurance is a breach of contract and can result in your insurance being cancelled.

 

#4 Accidents

You can cancel your car insurance, but unfortunately you can’t cancel the possibility of an accident.

 

Even if you rate yourself a good driver, you don’t have control over what other people do on the road. If you’re involved in a crash— big or small —you could find yourself footing the bill not only for your car but for the other person’s, too.

 

Having to fork out for car repairs or a new vehicle when you’re already financially strained can be catastrophic.

Reasons not to cancel your car insurance

#3 Theft

South Africa is lekker. But it’s also full of crime. The latest available SAPS annual crime stats (2022/3) show carjacking was at an all-time high – with 22 702 vehicles hijacked in a single year. 37 461 vehicles were reported stolen that same year. That’s about 165 incidents a day!

 

If your car gets taken and you don’t have insurance, that’s it kanti. Unless you have savings for a new car or a rich uncle or tannie to help you out, you’re officially without wheels now.

 

Worse still, if your financed car gets stolen or hijacked and you don’t have insurance, you’ll be stuck paying off a vehicle loan for a car you don’t have.

 

Imagine that on top of your existing financial stresses?

 

#2 Maintain your good rating and cheaper premiums

Cancelling your insurance and the resulting uninsured period on your track record can mean higher premiums when you want to take insurance out in the future.

 

Insurance companies base the cost of premiums on several factors, including your risk profile – the higher risk you are, the higher your premium.

 

A gap in your insurance could mean that you drove uninsured, which they take as a sign that you’re willing to take risks. It also shows you’re financially unstable, which means there’s a higher chance that you’ll miss future payments.

 

Smiling driver behind the wheel, protected by car insurance

 

#1 Why cancel when you can get cheaper?

If you’re thinking about cancelling your insurance because it’s too expensive, consider rather switching up your policy to a more affordable option (if your finance contract allows it).

 

But the best option of all is to shop around for a better deal. Not only will you pay less each month, but you’ll keep the same level of cover you enjoyed previously – maybe even more!

 

Hippo.co.za makes looking for car insurance easy by giving you 110 side-by-side quotes from some of South Africa’s top car insurers.

 

That way you can compare and choose the coverage that best suits your budget.

 

Use our free online comparison tool to find and compare the cheapest car insurance quotes, and get a no-obligation quote today.


Related Articles

2026-07-14

7 reasons you should consider Life Insurance

Life Insurance tends to sit at the bottom of the financial to-do list. It's benefits are not as immediate as the car payment or as tangible as the medical aid debit order every month. But for South Africans in their 30s and 40s, navigating growing responsibilities and a stack of debit orders that seems to get taller every year, it's one of the more consequential decisions you'll make.

Read More

2026-07-04

Introducing Hippo 2.0: Hippo's new and improved platform

Hippo 2.0 was rebuilt to make finding cover simpler, faster and more personal. It's mobile-first, easier to navigate and, with the Hippo guiding you at every step, a lot nicer to use.

Read More

2026-07-02

Comprehensive Car Insurance vs Third Party only: What's the difference?

Third-party liability insurance only can seem like a cost-saving option over comprehensive insurance, but an incident involving your car could end up costing you more than you bargained for.

Read More

2026-05-28

How to decode the fine print in your insurance contract

Insurance policies can look similar on the surface, but the fine print often reveals important differences in cover, exclusions, and claim conditions. Understanding these details can help you avoid surprises and choose protection that truly meets your needs.

Read More